Add Candidate Feedback And Scorecards Without An Interview
Last Updated: 30 October 2026
Summary
You can now record feedback on a candidate even when no interview was booked in Plumm, for example after a phone call, an event or an external conversation. [TO VERIFY]
- General candidate feedback sits on the candidate's profile in the Candidate Pool. It isn't linked to any job. [TO VERIFY]
- Job feedback without a booking is added on an application using a scorecard. You can fill it in yourself now, or assign it to a colleague to complete later. [TO VERIFY]
Adding feedback never creates an application or an interview, and never moves the candidate to another stage. [TO VERIFY]
This article is for hiring managers, recruiters, interviewers and Hire admins.
In This Article
- Before You Begin
- Step 1: Add General Candidate Feedback
- Step 2: Add Job Feedback Without An Interview
- Step 3: Assign A Scorecard To A Colleague
- Step 4: Complete A Scorecard Assigned To You
- Step 5: View Feedback
- Settings And Options
- Limitations
- Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) And Troubleshooting
Before You Begin
- Hire must be included in your organisation's contract. [TO VERIFY]
- Access comes from Admin > Permissions > Hire. There is no new permission or setting to turn on. [TO VERIFY]
| Action | Who Can Do It |
|---|---|
| Add general or job feedback | Users with Add Candidate, Edit Candidate, or a scorecard permission (Add, Edit or View Scorecard) who can see the candidate [TO VERIFY] |
| Read feedback | Users who can see the candidate or application and have View Evaluation [TO VERIFY] |
| Assign a scorecard to a colleague | Users with the existing Hire permission for assigning interviewers and scorecards [TO VERIFY] |
| Complete a booked interview scorecard | The named interviewer, after the interview start time (unchanged) [TO VERIFY] |
For general feedback, you can pick any scorecard set up by your admin. On a job, you need a relevant Screening or Interview scorecard configured for your company. If none is set up, Plumm shows a message instead of the scorecard list. You don't need permission to manage the scorecard library. [TO VERIFY]
Step 1: Add General Candidate Feedback
- Open the candidate's profile from the Candidate Pool. [TO VERIFY]
- Go to Evaluation and click Add Feedback. [TO VERIFY]
- Feedback Relates To is set to General Candidate Feedback. If you can see the candidate's applications, you can choose one instead. [TO VERIFY]
- Choose a format:
- Custom Feedback: write your feedback in the text editor (up to 5,000 characters). The helper reads: "Internal feedback about this candidate. It is not linked to a job." [TO VERIFY]
- Use Scorecard: search for and select any scorecard your admin has created (Screening, Interview or General [TO VERIFY: General type]).
- Click Submit. A message confirms "Feedback added successfully." [TO VERIFY]
Step 2: Add Job Feedback Without An Interview
- Open the candidate's application on the job, at any stage. [TO VERIFY]
- Click Add Feedback. It is linked to that application by default. [TO VERIFY]
- Select a scorecard. A scorecard is required for job feedback, and free text alone can't be used. [TO VERIFY]
- Complete the scorecard and submit. The feedback shows "Not linked to a Plumm booking". [TO VERIFY]
When moving a candidate to an interview stage, the move window now gives you separate options: Move Without Scheduling, Assign Scorecard or Add Feedback Now. [TO VERIFY]
Step 3: Assign A Scorecard To A Colleague
- On the application, choose Assign Scorecard. [TO VERIFY]
- Select the scorecard and one or more interviewers. The helper reads: "The interviewer will complete this scorecard later." [TO VERIFY]
- Confirm. A message shows "Scorecard assigned." Each person you chose gets a pending scorecard to complete. [TO VERIFY]
No calendar invitation or booking is created. [TO VERIFY]
Step 4: Complete A Scorecard Assigned To You
- Open the candidate and go to Evaluation. Your pending scorecard is listed there and in the relevant interview area. [TO VERIFY]
- Complete it and click Submit. [TO VERIFY]
If the scorecard is linked to an interview that hasn't happened yet, you'll see "Feedback can be submitted from [date, time and time zone]" and Submit stays disabled until then. [TO VERIFY]
Step 5: View Feedback
In Evaluation, each item shows its context (General, the application, or Copied), the author and the time it was submitted. Notes stay in their own Notes section. [TO VERIFY]
Feedback copied from another job or from the Candidate Pool also shows who copied it, when and where from. See Copy Feedback And Notes Between Jobs. [TO VERIFY]
Settings And Options
| Option | Details |
|---|---|
| Feedback Relates To | General Candidate Feedback (default on the profile), or a specific application [TO VERIFY] |
| Custom Feedback | Rich text, up to 5,000 characters. General feedback only. [TO VERIFY] |
| Use Scorecard | General feedback: any admin scorecard (Screening, Interview, General [TO VERIFY: General type]). Job feedback: a relevant Screening or Interview scorecard [TO VERIFY] |
| Assign Scorecard | Choose a scorecard plus one or more interviewers to complete it later [TO VERIFY] |
Limitations
- Job feedback must use a scorecard. Free-text-only feedback is for general candidate feedback only. [TO VERIFY]
- Assigned scorecards have no due date or reminder settings. [TO VERIFY]
- Adding feedback doesn't create an interview booking, a calendar invite or an application, and doesn't change the candidate's stage. [TO VERIFY]
- Recordings and AI analysis are available only for interviews booked in Plumm. Feedback added without an interview doesn't get an AI evaluation. [TO VERIFY] whether it counts towards the candidate's overall score.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) And Troubleshooting
Can I Add Feedback For A Call That Happened Outside Plumm? Yes. Add General Candidate Feedback on the profile, or add job feedback with a scorecard on the application. [TO VERIFY]
Will Adding Feedback Move The Candidate To Another Stage? No. Feedback never changes the stage. [TO VERIFY]
Why Is Submit Disabled On My Scorecard? The scorecard is linked to an interview that hasn't started yet. You can submit from the date and time shown. [TO VERIFY]
Why Do I See "You no longer have permission for this action"? Your access changed while you were working. Refresh the page. If you still need access, ask your Hire admin to check Admin > Permissions > Hire. [TO VERIFY]
Can I Edit Feedback After It's Submitted? You can edit general or manual feedback you added yourself with Add Feedback. Interview scorecards stay final once submitted. Nobody can edit another person's feedback, and copied feedback is always read-only. [TO VERIFY: where the edit option is]