Skip to content
  • There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

Scorecards, Feedback and Notes

Last Updated: 6 November 2026

What you can see and do here depends on the permission group (role) your admin has given you. See Set Up Roles and Permission Groups.

What It Is and Who It Is For

Scorecards make sure every candidate is judged on the same skills. Plumm's AI scores screening answers against the screening scorecard. Interviewers fill in the interview scorecard after each interview. Everything comes together on the candidate's Evaluation tab, and the hiring team can leave internal notes.

This article is for recruiters, hiring managers and interviewers. For how scores and ratings are calculated, see Candidate Ratings and Scoring in Hire.

Prerequisites

  • Scorecards set up in Hire settings, or use Plumm's defaults. See Hire Settings: Candidate Tags, Scorecards, Data Retention and Pipeline (Admin).
  • A scorecard chosen when the screening or interview was scheduled.

Permissions by Role

Role What They Can Do
Super Admin and Hire Admin Manage scorecards, see all evaluations, add notes
Recruiter or hiring manager See evaluations and notes on their jobs, with View Candidate and View Job
Interviewer Fill in the scorecard for interviews they're on. Sees evaluations only if their role includes it

Default Scorecards

Plumm includes two scorecards you can use straight away instead of creating your own.

Scorecard Used For
Plumm Default Screening Scorecard Plumm's AI uses it to score screening answers
Plumm Default Interview Scorecard Interviewers use it to score the interview

To see one, go to Admin > Hire > Scorecard, click the three dots on it and select Preview. You can't edit or delete the default scorecards.

Interviewer: Fill In an Interview Scorecard

You can give feedback once the interview time has passed.

From the email:

  1. Open the interview email Plumm sent you and click Give Feedback.
  2. Score each skill on the scorecard.
  3. Add overall comments and your recommendation if you want.
  4. Click Submit.

From the candidate's profile:

  1. Open Hire > Candidate Pool and click the candidate's name.
  2. On the Interviews tab, click Add Feedback for the interview.
  3. Fill in the scorecard and comments, then click Submit.

Recommendations are No Hire, Not Sure, Average, Hire and Must Hire.

Recruiter: Read a Candidate's Evaluation

  1. Open the candidate and go to the Evaluation tab.
  2. Review the sections:
Section What It Shows
Compatibility analysis How well their qualifications, experience and skills match the job, rated 1 to 5, with an overall score and an explanation
Screening Analysis Ratings for each screening answer. Click a video answer to watch it, and change the playback speed if you want
Interview Scorecard Scores from each interviewer for each round. Pick an interviewer in the dropdown to see only their scorecard and comments
Feedback history and scorecards All feedback given so far

Add Notes and Tag People

  1. Open the candidate and find the Notes panel.
  2. Type your note.
  3. To tag a colleague, type @ and pick them from the list. They get an email about the note.
  4. Click Save.

Notes are internal. Candidates never see them. You can tag active users only.

Limitations

  • Default scorecards can't be edited or deleted. Create your own in Hire settings if you need different skills.
  • Interviews on Google Meet, Teams or face to face have no AI analysis. The interview scorecard is the only evaluation.
  • Interviewers can submit feedback only after the interview time.

FAQs and Troubleshooting

Why Can't I Give Feedback Yet? The interview time hasn't passed, or you're not on the interview panel.

Why Is There No Screening Analysis? The candidate hasn't answered the screening yet, or wasn't screened.

Can I Change My Feedback After Submitting? [TO VERIFY: whether submitted interview feedback can be edited]

Can Candidates See Scores or Notes? No. Evaluations and notes are for the hiring team only.

Related Articles

  • Candidate Ratings and Scoring in Hire
  • Screening and Interviews: Schedule, Run and Cancel
  • Hire Settings: Candidate Tags, Scorecards, Data Retention and Pipeline (Admin)